Welcome to the ZRecs Archives!

This site contains all posts from Z Recommends from its 2006 launch through Sept. 3, 2008. Z Recommends has moved to a new home at zrecommends.com. Feel free to browse through the great content here, and then come join the new ZRecs Network at zrecs.com!

Wednesday, August 08, 2007

Cooking Connections: Making Play Dough

Besides being ridiculously cheap and easy, making homemade play dough is a great way to introduce a young child to the practice of cooking in its most basic form, and presents a tangible result that may have greater impact than food that is eaten and then forgotten. Z has been very interested in play dough lately, so we made two batches the other day, with Z enthusiastically taking on the role of "cooker man" (her invented term) and doing most of the measuring, pouring, stirring and adulterating, with the help of me and her Learning Tower. In the spirit of Food Week, we thought we'd do a quick run-through of how to make great homemade play dough.

Mix the following ingredients in a pot:

1 c. flour
1 c. warm water
2 t. cream of tartar
1 t. oil
1/4 c. salt

I let Z do all of the measuring of ingredients except for the oil (it's in a big bottle and I didn't relish the idea of cleaning up spilled oil) and the salt (because, well, I'm superstitious and spilled salt is bad luck!). The recipe works fine with estimations of the above amounts of ingredients - I only had about 1/8 of a cup of salt for my second batch, and I think we got more than 2 teaspoons of the cream of tartar in the first batch, but the results were similar and both were great.

Z poured everything into the pot, then gave it a good stir over medium heat. When I declared it thoroughly mixed, she delighted in squeezing copious amounts of food coloring into the mixture.

Stirring will eventually get too rough for your child to handle, and you'll need to take over.

When your play dough is the consistency of the above photos, scrape it out onto a cutting board and knead it thoroughly. This is tricky, because it's hot. Best to poke and prod at it yourself a bit, and get the initial, messiest kneading taken care of, then handing it off to your toddler to finish up, or breaking it into one large and one small piece.

Z adored this play dough, and it was so easy that I went ahead and made a second batch while she played with the first.

Below, Z prepares her signature dish, half-circles ingeniously molded in half an Easter egg.

A few days later, Jeremiah made a third batch.

There are a few things that make this play dough recipe stand head and shoulders above the storebought stuff:

  • Custom colors: I used Wilton icing color for the vibrant pink color. The blue is standard-issue, storebought food coloring.
  • None of that odd Play-Doh smell
  • Smoother and more pliable, less crumbly
  • Very cheap, and produced in much larger batches for maximum fun
  • Your child can do it "all by myself" (with your help) and create their own plaything
Just make sure you store your play dough in an airtight bag when you're finished with it for the day, and it will last until it gets dirty. Don't be surprised if your toddler quickly blends the colors into one!

10 comments:

Laura said...

Maybe I missed this in your post but how high do you have the heat on? Thanks for the great recipe! I was just thinking my 17 month old might be ready for Play Dough, assuming I could keep her from eating it.

Jeremiah McNichols said...

@Laura: Hmm, we didn't even mention to turn the stove on! Medium heat is best.

Gretchen said...

My daughter's preschool made play dough for one class, and they made the mistake of adding orange oil to the recipe to make it smell "nice." I can just picture the conversation that led up to that - "Hey! Let's make something the kids aren't supposed to eat smell like food! Great idea!" Not ...

Just thought I'd share the info to prevent other parents from making the same mistake.

lace said...

A lot of the homemade playdough I have used leaves your fingers caked in salt. Did you have this problem? This in one reason I have not made my own.

Jennifer McNichols said...

@Lace: One of the things that I liked about this play dough is that it didn't leave any sort of residue or gross feeling on my hands. We used sea salt for the recipe because that's the only salt we have in the house so I don't know if that made the difference or not.

Karla Willett said...

I have so many fond memories of home made play dough. I used to love the salty taste it left on my fingers.

When my oldest was in daycare they made peanutbutter play dough. I thik it was a combination of just PB and powdered sugar. The funny thing is my daughter (who would never eat) at her whole portion of PB playdough. :)

phyllis said...

i love making playdough, i have a similar recipe. but i use kool-aid packets for the coloring, it makes great colors and it also makes it smell a little bit fruity, which is nice. (no one ever thinks it's edible) my son's preschool has a "playdough" mom each month and i just make 2-3 batches and they're set for a whole month!

lace said...

I just tried the playdough recipe and was glad to see it did not leave any residue. I was still slightly skeptical even after you said it did not leave residue.

Thank you for posting this recipe. My 3 year old niece loved making playdough with me. She is now making birthday cake for me.

I believe I will be making playdough instead of buying it.

Mary said...

I'm wondering, could you use natural food colorings?

Jeremiah McNichols said...

@Mary: Absolutely! Do you have any knowledge to share?